Is Brandon Cutler Making a Comeback to AEW?

Brandon Cutler, a familiar face in All Elite Wrestling since its inception in 2019, has recently sparked speculation about a potential return to AEW television. In a candid interview with Masters of Wrestling, Cutler discussed his current status and the possibility of rejoining AEW’s programming.

Cutler’s last appearance on AEW television occurred during a Royal Rampage battle royal in July 2024. Since then, he has been relatively inactive on major AEW broadcasts. However, he has continued to make appearances in Ring of Honor (ROH), with his most recent match being a loss to Serpentico on ROH HonorClub TV in January 2025. Additionally, Cutler has been active on the independent wrestling circuit, recently facing Alec Price at Alpha-1 Wrestling’s “A1 the Purge” event on July 20. 

During the interview, Cutler expressed a flexible outlook on his future in AEW, stating, “It’s crazy. It’s wrestling, you can never see into the future. It’s a thing I’ve learned is never say never on anything, and everything is a possibility.” This statement has led fans and industry insiders to wonder if AEW might have plans to reintroduce Cutler into its storylines. 

Known for his role as a supporting character alongside The Young Bucks, Cutler’s on-screen presence has been characterized by his comedic antics and loyal camaraderie. His potential return could add a layer of continuity and nostalgia for long-time AEW viewers. Whether he would reprise his previous role or take on a new persona remains to be seen.

As AEW continues to evolve its programming, the inclusion of familiar faces like Cutler can serve to enrich its storytelling and engage its audience. While there is no official confirmation of his return, Cutler’s recent comments suggest that discussions may be underway.

For now, fans can only speculate about what the future holds for Brandon Cutler in AEW. His openness to returning indicates that the door remains ajar, and in the world of professional wrestling, that’s often all it takes for a comeback to become a reality.